First Reformed is the latest from Paul Schrader, a legendary filmmaker known for penning such classics as Taxi Driver, Raging Bull and The Last Temptation of Christ. Our story follows Rev. Toller (Ethan Hawke), a man in his mid-forties running First Reformed Church, a historical landmark owned by a local megachurch. Toller is preparing the grounds for a special anniversary service, which will host a star-studded congregation and be simulcasted to the megachurch. Meanwhile, he begins counseling a young pregnant couple, as the wife Mary (Amanda Seyfried) is concerned about her husband Michael’s lack of drive and his desire to have an abortion.
Schrader’s works are known for protagonists suffering great personal turmoil and struggle, and this film is no different. Toller is a complex man with many problems, both internal and external, and First Reformed is a complex and compelling exploration of what factors lead to his personal crisis. It may not end up as Schrader’s most memorable film, but it is certainly a return to form for the veteran as he has crafted a truly remarkable work. *SPOILERS AHEAD!*